I prefer the WDJ list to this website myself. I know who the WDJ reviewers are and their qualifications. Th website is anonymous and therefore -- who the heck are these people? Why should I believe their judgements and what personal biases might they have? Why won't they put their names to their reviews? That's my own personal take -- I just don;t like anonymous sites. It also does differ from the WDJ list many times.
Given that most dogs never have a single problem with corn or wheat, and that most allergies are to beef, chicken, egg and dairy as well as sometimes, grains, I also take recommendations based on certain ingredients with a pretty big grain of salt (so to speak!).
If breeders and trainers have had consistent good results with a food over many years, I prefer that recommendation to opting for a food based on the latest trendy ideas and ingredients. There are a lot of self-appointed experts on what is in dog foods now especially on the internet --- and oddly most people eat all these ingredients themselves even though similar things cause allergies in humans. And daily, we eat plenty of preservatives etc -- and do not think twice. Look at what is in your typical cookie/biscuit, chocolate treat, or pizza, or ready meal, or soup, or the preservatives in any packaged meat product you eat -- sausages, bacon, ham, lunch meats -- you and your children and partner are eating regularly all the stuff you won't feed your dog.
A recent extensive study showed as well that in 70% of cases where parents were sure their children had allergies, they did not. I would say the same holds for dogs.
Given that in the wild, canids eat rotting meat and carrion crawling with god knows what (few canids actually hunt and take down healthy animals -- they scavenge old dead things or cull the sick, the aged and the young) , I think a quality kibble of any type is a perfectly healthy option. I do like to avoid preservatives just as I do in my own food. I like adding some real food and not relying totally on a kibble and sometimes make homecooked. Very few wild dogs that I have heard of ever hunt down or scavenge rosemary oil, potatoes, salmon oil, dried kelp, dandelion, rosehips or many of the things that it says are in the food I am feeding at the moment.
Common sense is very useful when looking at animal foods, go with what you can afford and is of a quality you prefer but don;t get all wound up about it. :lol: And while we are this inspired we should all improve our own diets to our dogs' levels. :lol: