View Full Version : electric fences and a dead cavalier

12th March 2008, 04:03 PM
I received sad news today that a missing young Irish cavalier, that I'd posted here a while back and which was 'contained' in an electric fence -- eg using an electric shock collar -- was now 'found' -- killed after being hit by a car.

This poor dog was unchipped, and unspayed.

I am totally opposed to electric collars for many reasons, the primary one being humane reasons -- not a single national humane organisation in the US, Canada, UK or Ireland supports the use of these electric fences, and most actively condemn them.

I know some people continue to use them regardless. But if people are not persuaded on humanitarian reasons, this is one of the many reasons these collars are a poor choice. Besides the fact that anyone or anything can simply walk up and take the dog, there is almost always something that is so compelling to the dog that a brief shock is worth it. Many dogs will simply forget the threat of the shock and the training when such a thing tempts them. For a bitch in heat there are very strong biological urges to take off after males. For other dogs it may be a squirrel, some kids, a bird, a dog they know.

In this case, this little blenheim was crushed by a car while still wearing her electric fence collar. :( :(

12th March 2008, 04:12 PM
OH that is so sad. The poor little thing.

12th March 2008, 04:38 PM
that's way too sad :(

12th March 2008, 04:48 PM
I agree,i think its just laziness on the part of the human,proper kennel or being in the house is the better alternative,i dont know why people put them on the dog.I have know of collers not working properly on dogs.People dont care that the dog is wandering around and into the paths of cars.People think they stick it on and i dont have to bother walking the dog or checking its were abouts.irrisponsible owners yet again........

12th March 2008, 05:00 PM
OMG!! That truly is horrific, the poor dog..........

Cleo's Person
12th March 2008, 05:07 PM
Oh the poor dog.

12th March 2008, 07:54 PM
maybe someone should try one on the owners:eek: who do this to the poor dog maybe theyll think twice next :rolleyes: time poor little thing :(

murphy's mum
12th March 2008, 07:57 PM
So sad. What a waste of a wee life:(

12th March 2008, 08:08 PM
oh my god the poor baby!!

12th March 2008, 09:12 PM
That is so sad. We have a nice backyard grassy area with a patio, which is fenced and gated securely. Our cavalier has no interest in being out there unless it is out the doggie door to take care of "business". She loves to play outside ONLY WHEN we are out there sitting with her.

Having an electric fence and collar suggests that people who use them are sending their dogs outside with no lead, and no monitoring whatsoever. That just doesn't make sense with this breed. I can guarantee that mine would take the shock and run off to chase something or find a friend to be with, and as Karlin mentioned, what is to stop a large agressive (uncollared) dog from coming into the "fenced" area and attacking your pup? Some people just have no clue whatsoever! :swear:

12th March 2008, 09:14 PM
poor little girl
---Aileen and the gang (Barney---Jazzie---Sam)